Tag Archives: Draghi

Europhoria No More

In 2011 and 2012, the Eurozone was on the brink of destruction. Investors were preparing for a Greek exit from the Eurozone and some experts were even questioning the very existence of the European Union. However, in two years, much has changed. Today, the possibility of Greece leaving the Eurozone or of Cyprus becoming insolvent seems like a distant memory and after two years of being in recession, the Euro area has finally generated positive growth. The growth is slow, but is nevertheless positive.

How did the Eurozone manage this turnaround? Well, we can all thank the European Central Bank (ECB) for this. In July of 2012, ECB President Mario Draghi announced that the, “ECB would do whatever it takes to preserve the Euro.” In addition with this speech, the ECB extended the maturities on the loans it gave to European banks (called Long Term Refinancing Operations) and announced a new program (called Outright Monetary Transactions) where for the first time, it promised to purchase the sovereign bonds of financially troubled nations, given that they agree to implement certain fiscal reforms (tax hikes, spending cuts, etc.).

The ECB used a tricky monetary maneuver called sterilization to make sure that LTRO didn’t increase the European money supply the way FED’s QE did and until today, no country in the Eurozone has actually applied for a bailout through Outright Monetary Transactions. However, the mere existence of these programs created a sense of security in the Eurozone and they helped reduce the sovereign bond yields of Eurozone nations that had been inflicted by the crisis. For you bond newbies, the lower the interest rate on a bond, the less riskier it is deemed by the market. The graph below does a good job in visualizing Spanish and Italian bond yields in relation with ECB actions.

whatever_it_takes

In fact, one could argue that the sovereign bond yields of periphery Eurozone countries have dropped too low. For example, on the day that I have written this post, 10-year Spanish government bonds are yielding 2.68% whereas 10-year German bonds are yielding 1.27% . That means that the spread between the country with the highest unemployment rate in the developed world and the safest economy in the Eurozone is less than 2%. Back in August of 2012, that spread was about 6%. Even when Apple issued 10 year bonds in April of this year, their bonds yielded 3.45%. I think its safe to say that the markets have treated periphery Eurozone nations rather kindly.

50323907

Despite the irregularities in the bond markets, its hard to deny that the Eurozone has been in a honeymoon period for the last two years. However I realized that something is rotten in the state of Denmark, France, Italy, Spain, and all the other Eurozone countries (that was a Shakespeare joke. Read a book people). when a couple of months ago, I got a phone call from my good friend Mario Draghi.

Mario Draghi
“Buddy, I need your help with something. Come on over quick. Party at Merkel’s place afterwards.”

Even though I had a very busy schedule, I couldn’t say no to one of my oldest friends. So I decided to take the trip down to Frankfurt. Here I am outside the ECB.

10371762_10152255115070889_1152417560014958843_n (1)

I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve been there but I still have to go through security. Its so annoying. Anyway; when I walked into his office, Draghi seemed worried. He told me that the Eurozone is on the brink of negative inflation, otherwise know as deflation. The ECB’s target inflation rate has been 2% for the past several years. However, as the graph below shows, Euro area inflation has been below 1% since November of last year. In fact, just last month, several European countries including Greece, Cyprus and Hungary observed negative rates of inflation.

euro-area-inflation-cpi (2)Even those of us who haven’t received an education in economics have been told to fear inflation. However, deflation can be just as bad, if not worse. I’m pretty sure I explained this in a previous post but deflation has two main negative impacts. First of all, deflation discourages spending. Why should a sensible person purchase something today if he knows that it will be cheaper and more affordable tomorrow. This situation might seem profitable for an individual, but if everyone acts this way, then spending will decrease and the economy will come to a halt. Secondly, inflation has the ability to ease the cost of borrowing. Imagine that I take on a loan. Because of inflation, the amount of money I borrowed becomes less valuable. However, the amount that I borrowed stays the same. Thus, it becomes easier for me to pay back my loan. In cases of deflation when a currency gains in value, the exact opposite happens and debt becomes harder to pay off.

Due to the austerity measures installed in many Eurozone countries following the debt crisis, the Eurozone economy is barely expanding. Draghi fears that deflation could push the Eurozone economy back into recession. One of the reasons that Draghi had his hands tied was because he had already lowered interest rates to nearly 0%. Yet, he was failing in spurring inflation. That was where I stepped in to give Draghi some advice. On June 5th, Draghi listened to everything I had to say and held a press conference. The cameraman zoomed in on Draghi so I didn’t make the shot but I was sitting right next to Draghi during the press conference.

Firstly, I realized that European banks were parking their money at the ECB. Thus, I urged Draghi to set the ECB deposit rate to a negative figure. Negative deposit rates can encourage banks to take their money out of the ECB and perhaps lend it to consumers and companies because they would actually be losing money for depositing their cash at the ECB. This would spur growth and much needed inflation. Draghi followed my advice and lowered the deposit rate to -0.1%. He also lowered the headline inflation rate to 0.15% from 0.25%

Secondly, in the final hours of our meeting, we came with an idea to initiate a new financing program called Targeted Long Term Refinancing Operations (TLTRO)  where banks can borrow money from the ECB equivalent to as much as 7 percent of their outstanding loans to non-financial corporations and households. The loans will be given for 4 years. However, if these institutions don’t lend out the money they get from these loans, we will cut their maturities to two years.

Finally, I told Draghi to always have an ace of spades in his back pocket, in case the worst comes to worst. That ace of spades, would be outright bond purchases, just like Quantitative Easing in the US. We came to the conclusion that its better to wait and see how the Eurozone economy reacts to the policies we came up with that day, but letting the markets now that just like back in 2012, we would do whatever it takes to spur inflation in the Eurozone will help increase inflation expectations. Those are the unorthodox policies that Draghi touched on towards the end of his speech. Bond yields are already very low and QE in the United States has shown that bond purchases don’t necessarily spur inflation. However, the idea of bond purchases being a possibility will definitely play a role in protecting the Euro from appreciating.

After working for hours to come up with these policies, we finally called it a night and decided to go to Angela Merkel’s mansion in Berlin for a wild party. It was strictly BYOB. Apparently Merkel is tired of buying everyone drinks. All those bailouts in Southern Europe may be to blame. I can’t tell you what went down in that party. Lets just say that many world leaders wouldn’t want the pictures to leak to the press.

Popping champagne.
This is only the pregame.

Following Draghi’s press conference in June, Eurozone inflation remained stable at 0.5%. Draghi gave me a phone call last week and thanked me for his help. I told him that he owes me one and I gave him one final piece of advice.  I told him to publish the minutes from the ECB meetings, just like the way the FED does them. This would not only give the ECB some much needed transparency but would also increase the effect that his decisions have on market expectations.

draghinew_2268475b

As you can see, my friend Draghi looks awfully cute when he is happy. I hope his happiness continues and that the Eurozone can get out of this deflationary trend soon. In the globalized world that we live in, our economies are extremely interconnected. Thus, the fate of one large economy can have an effect on all of our countries and all of our lives.

“If we do not resolve the euro crisis, we will all pay the price. And if we do resolve it, we will all benefit”
-Mario Draghi

 

 

 

Advertisements